The Strange Case of Higreaves: My 1976 Childhood Story

In 1976, during the big summer drought, I wrote one of my first full‑length stories: Higreaves. I was ten years old. I shared a crowded bedroom with my identical twin, Eve. Our creativity often spilled into stories, drawings, pantomimes and games.

But something is terribly wrong with ‘Higreaves’ (not of the common spelling, Hargreaves).

Higreaves forms a window into a sinister corner of my subconscious. To something I mustn’t see.

This post explores my strange story, imagery, and what it says about my early childhood. For this is what fuelled my story. My toddlerhood to be precise.
 
Drawing showing characters wearing masks
Drawing reconstructing the story. Everyone is wearing masks and falling unconscious. Image right shows the original document.

A Childhood Story about a Real Event


Higreaves is set in a “park,” I can now see it was really our garden. The lamppost, the laurel tree, the lawn — all can be found in my garden. It’s not a park at all.

The story opens with a ‘Mr Jenesy’ sweeping the ‘park’. A passer‑by called Mr Smith, notices odd wheelbarrow‑like tracks end abruptly at a fence. How odd. On the other side lies a swamp.

This ‘swamp’, I have come to learn was the moniker of a pond at the bottom of the garden, for weeds and nettles overgrowing the banks. It wasn’t really a swamp at all.

Only later did I learn that builders had buried this pond during my toddlerhood. I have no memory of this pond at all, yet I wrote about a ‘swamp’ in my story.

I am writing about something I cannot consciously remember.
 

My book analysing my children's stories. Click to buy from Amazon.

Smith becomes obsessed with these strange tracks. Miss Bentley, a young woman, tells him they are not wheelbarrow tracks at all. At this moment, Higreaves himself appears, snarling and sniping, driving the two characters away.

At the time, I couldn’t understand why I wrote about tracks leaping over things. In fact, my story operates in two timelines: one before the fence existed, and one after. The tracks end at the pond because that is where they originally went — straight into the water. Ie, the pond. Once upon a time, that fence wasn’t there.

Masks, Drowning and the Uncanny Reveal


The story gets stranger. Jenesy corners Smith, shouting at him to leave. A tree “rips off his face” to reveal Higreaves real face beneath — Jenesy was wearing a mask. Higreaves tries to push Smith into the swamp, but falls in himself.

What’s this stuff about ‘masks’? And drownings? What’s got into my ten-year-old self?

Smith hears a girl scream. This scream is not fictional. It’s a real scream. I heard it insomuch as I saw that pond. The scream is mine.

That girl is me.

Later, Smith encounters Miss Bentley again, but she is already dead. She had been wearing Higreaves’ face during the swamp struggle. Miss Bentley is now ‘Higreaves’. He is wearing her mask.

Masks, Mistaken Identity, Drowning and Murder.


What is this story?

The story spirals into a black hole:
  • Higreaves drugs Smith with sleeping pills
  • Jenesy faints while calling the police
  • Higreaves is knocked out with a narcotic plant
  • And a burning smell reveals Higreaves’ lethal weapon by the swamp

How nonsensical this story might seem. But the “leaping” tracks now make sense. Those tracks are mine. Of a child running. Escaping something. I ran into the pond. Before it was buried, and a fence was erected in front.

Eventually, a policeman called Detective Saturday arrives to find:
  • Miss Bentley dead in the swamp
  • Higreaves unconscious in the garage
  • And sleeping pills scattered everywhere

The story ends with a question that haunts me still:

What happened in that pond?

The Hidden Meaning Behind Higreaves


When I revisit Higreaves now, I see a young child trying to express something terrible she had lived through. In 1968, a nasty big man chased a toddler into a pond. He was Mum’s half-brother and the toddler was me. I lost consciousness hence characters falling unconscious. He assaulted me there, hence the burning sensation.

Just as in my earlier stories, I was projecting my early experiences onto fictional characters. I was wearing masks to tell a story about myself.

My later writing would continue to return to themes of drowning, burning, missing children and blacking out. My book, Tales from Daler Cottage provides a full analysis of this and my other early children’s stories.

If you’re new to my memoir

Comments

Intro

Welcome — I’m Madeleine Watson, a memoirist, artist and diarist. For more than forty years I’ve lived a lie. I have documented my journey to the dark truth about my toddlerhood through writing, artwork and research. This blog brings together everything I've discovered at the age of 51 — a discovery that reshaped everything I believed about myself.

My work spans childhood trauma, identity, memory, twinhood and the ways early experiences echo through adult life. Here you’ll find memoirs, diary excerpts, artwork, family‑history, research and reflections drawn from decades of personal documentation.

If you’re new, the best place to begin is the Start Here page, which introduces the prologue and the 10‑part series that leads to the moment I learned the truth about my past. You can also visit About Me to learn more about my background and the purpose behind this project.

Thank you for reading.

Popular posts from this blog

Prologue: My Beliefs Before Discovering the Truth About My Toddlerhood

Part 1: The Day My Life Began to Change — A Mother’s Panic and a Buried Memory

The Hidden Message Behind My 1985 Railway Tunnel Paintings: 23 Aug - 18 Sep 1985

How Childhood Trauma Shaped My Behaviour as a Sunday School Teacher at Fifteen: 15 February - 1 November 1981

The Haunted House – A Children’s Short Story from My Early Writing

The Hidden Message Behind the Derelict Barn: 15 July – 21 September 1986

My Childhood Diaries: How My Early Journals Revealed the Truth About My Lost Toddlerhood

The Doll Pantomimes: How Childhood Play Revealed My Hidden Trauma

Part 2: The Novels That Exposed My Buried Trauma — How Fiction Revealed What I Couldn’t Remember

Part 3: My Twin’s Childhood Accident — The Day That Triggered a Hidden Memory